New Derren Brown TV Special
On Easter Monday, April 25th at 9pm, my new special DERREN BROWN: MIRACLES FOR SALE will air on C4. This is hot off the press, so I have no artwork to show you as yet.
This is the special about faith-healing that some of you will have heard about. It has been the most intensely difficult project that I have attempted: to train an ordinary member of the public as a faith healer, then take him out to Texas, the heart of the Bible Belt, and try to pass him off as the real deal. We filmed this at the end of last year amidst concerns that we had bitten off far more than we could chew.
The film we made is driven by a desire to expose what I consider to be a foul and dangerous fraud at the expense of the sick, the needy and the faithful all over the world. It is not a comment on the church, or belief, or even, before some people get upset, the idea that God can or can’t heal. It is about a specific fraud, a greedy trick that has nothing to do with God whatsoever, beyond the fact that his name gets shouted around a lot. We made the show with the involvement of Christians and pastors who had been involved in that particular scene.
No faith healer has ever been able to provide evidence of a single miraculous healing ever having had occurred. Some when pushed have offered a few success stories, but when those ‘healed’ people have been approached, they turn out to be the same as before, worse than ever, dead, or not to have had the ailment in the first place. What does seem to happen, though, is a cleverly-engineered emotional event brings people into a state of hype that releases adrenalin, which acts as a pain killer. People in the audience with low-level ailments that can respond to such pain relief – combined with a huge amount of expectation and a desire to be healed, or ‘close to the magic’ – will commonly find themselves pain-free and step forward when asked to. There then follows, at the larger events, a filtering process where stewards send back anyone with a serious or visible ailment (such as an arm missing) and test the remaining arthritics and bad-back sufferers to see if they can display a convincing pantomime of having been healed (touching toes and so on). There are other tricks to seemingly cure the blind and deaf which I will also demonstrate on the show. These poor people are then brought up on stage in their heightened state to bounce around and think they’re healed while the truly afflicted are left to believe God hasn’t taken much of an interest. It’s very disturbing to see the rows of the seriously disabled on drip machines, in wheelchairs and even hospital beds, ignored and invisible, safely behind the TV cameras’ reach at the big-name events. Or to hear of the chronically afflicted being carried to these rallies around America by families who spend every last penny they earn in hope that the man on stage might channel a little of God in their direction. A wake of despair is left behind by these charlatans, made up of hundreds of thousands of people who receive no healing or only temporary pain relief, and are encouraged to blame themselves for not having enough faith when they find nothing’s improved.
And then there’s the money. This is the hub of the whole operation. The financial motivation seems to be closely linked to something called the Prosperity Gospel, which has to be the most perverse and self-serving piece of scripture-twisting I have ever come across. It was loudly preached by Oral Roberts and made popular in the 90s, and takes the rather lovely idea of ‘sow and ye shall reap’ and re-defines it as a financial incentive. Jesus bestows his blessings in the form of money. How do you get these blessings? You first give money. More than you can afford, otherwise it doesn’t count. Jesus will repay you hundredfold. If he doesn’t, you probably didn’t give enough, or perhaps you have secret sin or not enough faith. And to whom do you give your money? Your preacher, naturally. You might want to read that through again if this logic is something new to you. Not surprisingly, the big name preachers earn far more than any Hollywood A-lister from this system. Proof of the fact that Jesus bestows his blessings in the form of money? The stinking richness of your pastor. Perhaps his fleet of private jets might just convince you. And these donations come in not just from a mesmerised flock gathering twice on a Sunday, they flood in from millions of people on mailing lists which form the backbone of the big business of faith healing. The TV rallies, the crusade events, are all designed to encourage people to sign up and send in a sizeable chunk of their earnings every month. Cash floods in tax-free (for as long as you say it’s a church you are pretty much left alone by the IRS) and is spent on lifestyles that in some cases reach beyond imaginable luxury. People imagine perhaps that the money goes somewhere worthwhile to support God’s work. It’s disheartening watching the sick and the elderly put cash they can’t afford into the donation buckets at these vast crusades when I hear of how one big-name healer spent thousands of dollars after a rally, in said cash, on hotel room service and rent boys.
The healers perform their shows over here too: I recently went to see a couple of the current main men at venues in London and have never felt such a heady mixture of disgust and deep pity. A girl behind me screamed to her friend ‘There’s your proof God can heal!’ as we watched a man climb out of his wheelchair on stage; in her delight, she missed the moment later when he collapsed unhappily back into it once the cameras had been swiftly pointed away from him. At least it was his own chair: another common trick is to quietly stick someone with a bad back into one of the healer’s own wheelchairs to ‘make things comfortable’ for them, so that once they are brought before the crowd, the glistening man of God can command them to rise from a chair they didn’t need in the first place. Praise the Lord.
The project was hugely difficult because a big business like faith healing is almost impenetrable. We tried to speak to those who had worked alongside the current big-name healers, as we knew of a few who had been allowed in the inner circles of trust and knowing the depths of the corruption had eventually turned against it. But these are people who live in fear. They were told for years by their charismatic, ruthless leaders that they lived under a curse and that to leave the clan would result in God ending their lives. Disturbingly, that may not always be too far from the truth: we heard of a couple of witnesses who had been brought to testify against a healer and had died mysteriously of heart attacks the night before the trial. Something dark may be afoot.
There is, as one might hope, a growing scepticism in Britain amongst Christians towards these so-called healers. Although I don’t hide my own lack of religious belief, my repulsion at this scam comes as much from my days as a Christian as it does from simply being a human being observing ego- and money- driven fraud. It was a gruelling journey to penetrate the world of that fraud in the small way we could, with our own particular journey of seeing if an ordinary guy could pass as a real healer. I hope that the ranks of intelligent believers will feel the same concern at our findings as the rest of the viewers.
I am a Christian though not a fanatic. I think that Derren is doing a great service by helping to expose wolves in sheep’s clothing. It is disheartening to see how Jesus can be manipulated in this way at a huge cost to the sick and vulnerable. I believe that miracles do occur but that they are always explainable by natural causes – otherwise we would have proof that God exists. If we had proof, we wouldn’t need faith… I know that to the unbeliever this logic may seem fallacious but then miracles are never for the unbeliever.
I hope that Derren will maintain his balance and does not hurt honest believers as he exposes the charlatans because even though he no longer believes himself, he acts in a very moral and Christian way and in his heart is more of a Christian than many church goers
I look forward to watching this program, it is about time somebody took on these criminals in the mainstream media, and glad it is by somebody such as Darren Brown who has already proven his credentials in exposing fraudsters.
Do people actually read before commenting, Mr Brown clearly states “It is not a comment on the church, or belief, or even… the idea that God can or can’t heal”. So why do some commentator’s still insist on bringing religion into the discussion. The program is clearly not about religion but about exposing fraudsters who just so happen to use christianity as there cloak that protects them from the law. I’m sure that this program will present evidence that will help support anti-theists ideologies but that shouldn’t be an issue to believers of the religion in question.
I cannot wait to see this! I am so EXCITED! I get even more excited the more i see the adverts! :/ X
Hi
I am a Christian and have seen substantiated healings that can’t be explained including my own. A very unassuming humble lady in our church prayed for healing of my jaw before I went into hospital. The consultant took a new x ray to compare with the previous one that indicated that a potentially painful operation was necessary. Anyway he found the results difficult to comprehend and unfortunately I didn’t have the presence of mind to ask for copies of the x rays ( I don’t know if I could have had them anyway ). I have seen other healings that are not accompanied by extortionate requests for money. Well done Derren for exposing charlatans who abuse the name of Jesus, I would not wish to be in their shoes, and for others don’t write off the possibility that there is a God
tim minchin- stormDD
Finally someone has got the balls to expose this bulshi*e industry. it is the biggest scam going and financially ruining peoples lifes.
its a massive shame though, that god doesnt take more direct action on those people who take his name in vain, and who do nothing but add negativity to whatever religion the charlatans in question claim to represent…
amen…
I was in a tongue speaking Pentecostal church for 20 years that believed in faith healing (though at least they didn’t ask money for it). Yet I have never ever seen a single genuine miracle in all those 20 years! All the “healings” were always dubious and ambiguous, which well could be explained by natural processes (and never really big things). Often it was self-delusion described in the above article. How come there are NEVER undisputable cases and never really big miracles? Shouldn’t the Lord be stronger than this? Also: if there are genuine and true faith healings, like Len claims, shouldn’t the Lord punish those who cheat in his name? Shouldn’t the Lord be more angry with these people than he is with atheist, gays etc.?
When I analyzed Christians who claim they’ve indeed been healed, it always turned out there are aspects of their stories that they don’t tell at first and those would lead us to a natural explanation of their “healings”. They don’t necessarily want to lie, but they delude themselves too. I have seen a girl claiming to be healed from blindness. At first her story seemed convincing. She showed diagnoses (two – one before and one after the alleged healing) and everybody believed her. However I decided to examine the diagnoses and it turned out she wasn’t blind in the first place and she isn’t healthy now. She still has all the conditions she had before (bar some minor improvements), plus she also went under medical treatment which could well explain those minor improvements.
Sometimes the body naturally self-heals. Sometimes you hear from “miracle healings” and surprising health improvements from atheists and people who were never prayed for or who don’t even believe in this. So I’m sorry to say Len but your story is not very convincing to me. To convince you should first show the diagnoses before the alleged healing and after. We should see what was your exact problem and if it’s impossible that your condition would naturally improve. I guess it’s not and your body made a natural improvement on its own and now you delude yourself into thinking it was Jesus. How come there are never real miracles like limbs growing back? Didn’t Jesus promise his followers will perform bigger miracles than him?
And one more note: My father is a Christian of 20 years. He has faith, he is devout. But 10 years ago he got a brain stroke and he is tied to bed ever since. He prays, and prays and prays for a healing. He also got prayed for by pastors, faith healers and other Christians. Of course, he didn’t heal. In my church I have seen a pastor die of cancer. He didn’t get healed either, no matter how much he was prayed for. I’m not surprised. Real miracles never happen. Just small, ambigious health improvements which are most probably a result of natural processes of the body or self-delusion.
I’m so looking forward to this show, roll on 9pm!
I commend you for looking at these charlatans and exposing them for the fakes they are. I was sucked into this whole thing many years ago and wasted too much time and money with this nonsense.
those people need to be healed of their GREED of money
Well well i’m speechlessy – just shows how easy a target christianity is. I can’t wait for this imp to do a ‘documentary’ on other religions. Just because he has tried to show some ‘evidence’ doesn’t mean there are no miracles done by God through many christians.
Just finished watching the programme… What a journey that Derren and the whole team had been through to accomplish the mission, and I greatly admire the bravery, and the strong will of everyone in the team in proving fraudulent so-called faith healers. I genuinely do not understand why and why and why those people can do that just because of greed for money? Hope justice serves them right at then end of the day, and my heart goes out to all their victims… Thank you Derren, Nathan, and the whole team for daring to expose such an ugly truth, and hopefully this verdict will spread to as many as possible.
Just finished watching the show. Very good. Well done. Having been involved to some extent with the ‘faith healing’ movement as an observer / believer and occasional participant, the show was of great interest. I made the link between the preachers’ methods, and hypnosis a good few years ago when I had studied and gained an understanding of the hypnotic effect. I have experienced the laying on of hands and falling over and had a temporary healing on my eye sight, which was more down to tiredness than a defect, at a meeting held by one of the BIG organisations featured on the show. I don’t think, and it would be wrong to say, that all the faith healers are con men. A lot of them believe that what they are doing is real.
I still believe in God, but not in the same way as before
But there are definitely a lot of con men too.
That bit with the information cards made me chuckle. I saw a well known mental illusionist do that recently, currently on tour.
Can you guess who it was? 😉
Saw you in Liverpool Derren. Genius. We know it’s all a con, However Some of it was astonishing and my mind boggled at how you acheived the effects.
Showmanship, confidence, and manipulation, same as in the churches, has an effect on an audience.
I saw this. It was junk TV. Waste of viewers money. Why go to America? Why not investigate here and tell people the truth? Why not show people some real God sent healing. The program was of the devil to show that Christianity is wrong. Else you should have shown the other side and explained that Christianity works – e.g. using Isaiah 53: 4-5. If Derren is so good why can’t he stop his baldness? This is EGO – edging God out. No wonder the UK is messed up and we Africabs have to use prayers to sustain the country. Derren like most of u have alchohol problems. Nathan – u need to repent big time. The program was ‘true’ but they used you for the wrong motive. You fell for Mr Brown’s tricks.
Enjoyable show-well done!
Brave to have Nathan, as he was not instantly likeable.
Hope a few people question their beliefs.
loved it.
As a Christian who believes God CAN do miracles but also that man is not an unreasonable worship-animal, I was encouraged and enterained by this special.
There is healing in the name of Jesus Christ, ask from GOD through HIS SON and you shall receive, seek and you shall find , knock and the door shalol be opened. The world is filled of evil and good and as there are good people in the world there are also bad ones. The Bible warns us of alse prophets:
Num 12:6 And he said, Hear now my words: If there be a prophet among you, I the LORD will make myself known unto him in a vision, and will speak unto him in a dream.
Mat 7:15 Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
Mat 7:16 Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
Mat 7:17 Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.
Open your eyes and ask of the LORD and he shal reveal alll to you, if only you ask.
Mat 7:18 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.
Mat 7:19 Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
Mat 7:20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.
Mat 7:21 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
Mat 7:22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works?
Mat 7:23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity [lawlessnessMat 24:11 And many false prophets shall rise, and shall deceive many.
Mat 24:12 And because iniquity [lawlessness] shall abound, the love of many shall wax cold].
Wale, please allow me to point out some problems with your post…
‘Waste of viewers money’ – no, it was comercial television and not paid for by viewers. It did, however, expose some fake healers and their methods, fake healers who do waste people’s money.
‘Why not show people some real God sent healing’ – because that was not the aim of the programme. There are a lot of programmes which claim already to do that. Why do you have a problem with the exposures of fakes? If you truely believe that there is genuine faith healing then surely you should applaud anyone who roots out the fakes?
Cont’d…
‘If Derren is so good why can’t he stop his baldness?’ – Derren does not claim to be able to do these things. You missed the point of the programme, it was to expose the fakes, those who are damaging Christianity from within.
Your anger should not be directed towards those who are trying to expose the liars, but at the liars themselves. Whether or not Derren shares your faith surely you are not so stupid as to defend everyone who claims to share your belief, even if they do so with one face whilst acting immorally and unethically with another?
Oh, and forgot to say, Derren, I loved the programme.
I would also like to express my respect for you and your team in deciding to sever ties with the Christian PR man when you realised that by using his contacts you would be damaging an innocent and, by all accounts, likeable man.
I can’t help thinking that had you continued to use him the conclusion of the show would have been more impressive, with a bigger audience, but you took the correct decision in putting your morals before the grand finale.
Hats off to you and all involved
Derren and his team have truly outdone themselves this time. I really appreciate the good work you are doing exposing people like this. I have had personal experience of faith healing giving false hope and causing sadness and I was really moved by your programme. Thank you.
Derren,
Big fan. What do you think about Theta healing? It looks like a scam to me. I know a few people in my life who are influenced by it and I find the claims of DNA changing rituals, healing acts and curing cancer (I am not kidding) weird and almost stupid.
I particularly wanted to ask you about one practice of theirs called muscle reading. where fingers are used to test the state of the subconscious. As a hypnotist what are your views? is it really accurate?
Really enjoyed watching this when it was on TV, the whole faith healing thing is questionable to say the least… Susan
I went to a healer once, was told I was healed, and when I came back and said, “no, still having problems” (with Crohn’s Disease), was told, “you WERE healed but you created the illness again instantaneously becuase you didn’t believe in the healing.”
Allrighty then!
I am a Christian and overall, I agree with your analysis of most Christian Healers, having witnessed many of them first hand, and I have yet to witness a true, verifiable healing. The healer usually calls out ailments like headaches, poor hearing or eyesght, or my favorite – one leg an inch shorter than the other. After being prayed over, the people are put on the spot before hundreds, or even thousands of people… a microphone is shoved in front of their face, and the pressure of hundreds of eyes on them, they are asked if they are healed. Invariably, the response is yes. What about the blind? The ones missing limbs etc.? Disappointing! However, unlike you, I do believe in a true miracle healing power from Christ. Just because we find bogus money, doesn’t mean all money is bogus!