New Derren Brown TV Special
On Easter Monday, April 25th at 9pm, my new special DERREN BROWN: MIRACLES FOR SALE will air on C4. This is hot off the press, so I have no artwork to show you as yet.
This is the special about faith-healing that some of you will have heard about. It has been the most intensely difficult project that I have attempted: to train an ordinary member of the public as a faith healer, then take him out to Texas, the heart of the Bible Belt, and try to pass him off as the real deal. We filmed this at the end of last year amidst concerns that we had bitten off far more than we could chew.
The film we made is driven by a desire to expose what I consider to be a foul and dangerous fraud at the expense of the sick, the needy and the faithful all over the world. It is not a comment on the church, or belief, or even, before some people get upset, the idea that God can or can’t heal. It is about a specific fraud, a greedy trick that has nothing to do with God whatsoever, beyond the fact that his name gets shouted around a lot. We made the show with the involvement of Christians and pastors who had been involved in that particular scene.
No faith healer has ever been able to provide evidence of a single miraculous healing ever having had occurred. Some when pushed have offered a few success stories, but when those ‘healed’ people have been approached, they turn out to be the same as before, worse than ever, dead, or not to have had the ailment in the first place. What does seem to happen, though, is a cleverly-engineered emotional event brings people into a state of hype that releases adrenalin, which acts as a pain killer. People in the audience with low-level ailments that can respond to such pain relief – combined with a huge amount of expectation and a desire to be healed, or ‘close to the magic’ – will commonly find themselves pain-free and step forward when asked to. There then follows, at the larger events, a filtering process where stewards send back anyone with a serious or visible ailment (such as an arm missing) and test the remaining arthritics and bad-back sufferers to see if they can display a convincing pantomime of having been healed (touching toes and so on). There are other tricks to seemingly cure the blind and deaf which I will also demonstrate on the show. These poor people are then brought up on stage in their heightened state to bounce around and think they’re healed while the truly afflicted are left to believe God hasn’t taken much of an interest. It’s very disturbing to see the rows of the seriously disabled on drip machines, in wheelchairs and even hospital beds, ignored and invisible, safely behind the TV cameras’ reach at the big-name events. Or to hear of the chronically afflicted being carried to these rallies around America by families who spend every last penny they earn in hope that the man on stage might channel a little of God in their direction. A wake of despair is left behind by these charlatans, made up of hundreds of thousands of people who receive no healing or only temporary pain relief, and are encouraged to blame themselves for not having enough faith when they find nothing’s improved.
And then there’s the money. This is the hub of the whole operation. The financial motivation seems to be closely linked to something called the Prosperity Gospel, which has to be the most perverse and self-serving piece of scripture-twisting I have ever come across. It was loudly preached by Oral Roberts and made popular in the 90s, and takes the rather lovely idea of ‘sow and ye shall reap’ and re-defines it as a financial incentive. Jesus bestows his blessings in the form of money. How do you get these blessings? You first give money. More than you can afford, otherwise it doesn’t count. Jesus will repay you hundredfold. If he doesn’t, you probably didn’t give enough, or perhaps you have secret sin or not enough faith. And to whom do you give your money? Your preacher, naturally. You might want to read that through again if this logic is something new to you. Not surprisingly, the big name preachers earn far more than any Hollywood A-lister from this system. Proof of the fact that Jesus bestows his blessings in the form of money? The stinking richness of your pastor. Perhaps his fleet of private jets might just convince you. And these donations come in not just from a mesmerised flock gathering twice on a Sunday, they flood in from millions of people on mailing lists which form the backbone of the big business of faith healing. The TV rallies, the crusade events, are all designed to encourage people to sign up and send in a sizeable chunk of their earnings every month. Cash floods in tax-free (for as long as you say it’s a church you are pretty much left alone by the IRS) and is spent on lifestyles that in some cases reach beyond imaginable luxury. People imagine perhaps that the money goes somewhere worthwhile to support God’s work. It’s disheartening watching the sick and the elderly put cash they can’t afford into the donation buckets at these vast crusades when I hear of how one big-name healer spent thousands of dollars after a rally, in said cash, on hotel room service and rent boys.
The healers perform their shows over here too: I recently went to see a couple of the current main men at venues in London and have never felt such a heady mixture of disgust and deep pity. A girl behind me screamed to her friend ‘There’s your proof God can heal!’ as we watched a man climb out of his wheelchair on stage; in her delight, she missed the moment later when he collapsed unhappily back into it once the cameras had been swiftly pointed away from him. At least it was his own chair: another common trick is to quietly stick someone with a bad back into one of the healer’s own wheelchairs to ‘make things comfortable’ for them, so that once they are brought before the crowd, the glistening man of God can command them to rise from a chair they didn’t need in the first place. Praise the Lord.
The project was hugely difficult because a big business like faith healing is almost impenetrable. We tried to speak to those who had worked alongside the current big-name healers, as we knew of a few who had been allowed in the inner circles of trust and knowing the depths of the corruption had eventually turned against it. But these are people who live in fear. They were told for years by their charismatic, ruthless leaders that they lived under a curse and that to leave the clan would result in God ending their lives. Disturbingly, that may not always be too far from the truth: we heard of a couple of witnesses who had been brought to testify against a healer and had died mysteriously of heart attacks the night before the trial. Something dark may be afoot.
There is, as one might hope, a growing scepticism in Britain amongst Christians towards these so-called healers. Although I don’t hide my own lack of religious belief, my repulsion at this scam comes as much from my days as a Christian as it does from simply being a human being observing ego- and money- driven fraud. It was a gruelling journey to penetrate the world of that fraud in the small way we could, with our own particular journey of seeing if an ordinary guy could pass as a real healer. I hope that the ranks of intelligent believers will feel the same concern at our findings as the rest of the viewers.
OOOHHHHH sounds very interesting, when i saw it was on easter monday i was hoping you were planning to rise rom the dead, ah well perhaps that can be next years easter special 😉
Fascinating, simply fascinating… I can’t wait to watch this!
This whole “healing” miricle is exactly the stunt that pastors on the ‘God Channel’ pull day after day.
Fruads such as the well known Benny Hinn perform this on a regular basis and get away with it with more money than he walked in with. You will notice how these pastors on this very popular TV channel consistantly pursuade the audience and people watching at home to buy their books.
I’ve always found it odd that redemption costs £12.99 or nearest offer.
Tricky subject Derren brave of you to take on and expose.I look forward to seeing it
Excited to see it! Something to look forward too 🙂
Derren Brown is a truly amazing man.
cant wait for the new show, sounds up to your usual high standards,
i have been trying to contact you as i have a really good idea for a new tv special, well i think it would be cool, would love to run it by you. you have my e-mail attached to this reply.
all the best
richard
Wow would really like to see it but unfortunate enough I live in new Zealand so will be months . Hope it turns out good for the best .
Why does this have to be on the day I go to see you in Sunderland? =(
It seems like a really interesting project, it’s just a shame that the people who really should/need to watch this wont, due to it being against their belief system. It’s about time that people see these charlatans for what they really are; conn-men and fraudsters.
Exciting! I’ve been craving a bit of Derren recently :o) Unfortunately I cant afford to see his show when it tours next month so this should do me nicely.
Always a pleasure to watch the specials.
Won’t miss it!
This sounds absolutely superb. I’m hoping there’s a nod to the excellent Steve Martin film “Leap of Faith” – which approaches this (seemingly well known) fraud from the inside out. Very much looking forward to it; kudos to Channel 4 for the Easter Monday slot… It doesn’t take divine intervention to predict the Daily Mail letters page over the subsequent days.
great subject. Look forward to the show. Keep up the energy derren.
Thank you for exposing these people, like you my disgust and despair comes from having been a Christian and a one time healer, (also a tarot reader and astrologer…. I’ve tried it all 🙂 I now study psychology and work as a therapist teaching people that the power and control over their lives comes from within themselves, not from sone invisible outside influence whether that be god, dead people or little green men!
That was quite a Blog post. I got teary when you described the desperate measures some people take to attend these events. I am looking forward to this special, but at the same time will undoubtedly feel uncomfortable watching it. Lets hope it helps bring much needed awareness.
Thanks for the heads up x
I’ve witnessed several incidents at church where these ‘healers’ suggest that everyone has different length calves which will cause arthritis in later life. They then go on the make up lean against a wall to pull at our legs. The finale is to make the person sit on a chair to prove that their legs are now identical lengths due to the powers of God. Although I do believe in God, I think that this is a bit far fetched and that they have ulterior motives.
Please remember that placebo can be valuable in and of itself. It should be used as a powerful tool. Human consciousness has, after all produced innumerable “miracles” of healing. Conventional medicine in truth is only a support to the human body in it’s own ability to heal. The prevalence of people who believe headache pills have rid them of the headache shows how ready people are to put the cart before the horse. Headache pills numb the pain. The body in it’s entirety mostly stop it from coming back once the pills wear off. In exactly the same way the rest of medicine works. Miracles of healing therefore are unwittingly rejected on the basis of semantics rather than mode of operation. I’m sure your show will be fascinating but I notice a preoccupation with exposing the “truth” as opposed to “faith” – the notion of which is absurd.
Much respect though I have to say – I think you’re a fascinating guy and always find your shows great entertainment.
Peace!
Thank you for this blog post and explaining in such detail about your new show, Derren. I had some idea what went on behind all this but to read it so starkly in black & white was truly shocking.
Has made me even more impatient to watch this show now. I can’t wait!
LC x
WHAT? You’re telling me the whole faith healing is a scam? I have seen with mine own eyes the miricales these people perform. They get cripples that nobody else knows and have not walked for 30 years to get out of their wheelchairs and do a jig for the cheering crowd. I even seen them turn little blind Tommy into a fully seeing child again whilst his Ma and Pa cried in the background. I just yesterday sent of a huge cheque to Pastor Jack Daniels in the hope that he could cure me of my drinking addiction. Hmmmmphhh looks like I am going to loose the house now. Wish I had seen this post yesterday.
Now on a serious note, it always surprises me how stupid these people really are, maybe it helps that I do not believe in an almighty being who is able to make things happen. But anyhoo can’t wait
Great stuff; charlatans like these really wind me up.
Yay, finally some new Derren stuff. I’ve been suffering withdrawal symptoms. Well, this has given some meaning to a pretty meaningless celebration for me! And it’s almost like they planned it to fall on Easter Monday 😉
This looks really interesting – I can’t wait to see the corrupt outed for the world to see.
Another Derren Brown master-stroke. 🙂
I know you know this Darren, but just want to check. Some frauds do not mean all frauds? Are u saying all healing in the name of God is a fraud?
I agree I can’t stand the TV ‘send me 121 dollars and you’ll be healed’ crap. But the logic that one fraud means all fraud can’t be right?
The dame logic says since hitler was a vegetarian all vegetarians are monster genocidal maniacs?
Sounds interesting! =)
Can’t wait. I have no doubt that all your efforts will be well worth it and it will be yet another intelligent, captivating programme. We really appreciate your work to investigate and expose unscrupulous people such as these. It’s always in a way that clearly demonstrates what they are doing for all to see. Keep up the excellent work!
I was unfortunate enough to have worked in an arena that hosted one of these events in the UK, and you couldn’t have summed up my feelings more accurately.
The feeling of heartache for people who had exhausted every other medical option and were there in complete desperation was painful enough, but then when it came to their donations and they were told, “Some people don’t know how much to give, but I say – ‘the bigger your need the more you should give'” it literally made me sick to my stomach.
People need to realise such opinions on these healers aren’t an insult to Christianity – it’s an insult to people that are taking advantage of the must vulnerable.
Can’t wait to watch this. Sounds very interesting!:-)
Derren I’m a huge fan of urs! I watch all ur stuff, over and over I might add, and always look forward to what u come up with!
However, I couldn’t disagree with you more on this topic Sir!! U say there is no proof of genuine miracle? Where have u been looking?? I’ve personally SEEN the blind SEE the Deaf hear and many other miracles and heres a BOLD Claim… I can prove IT!!! I challenge u Sir, to come to South Africa with ur film Crew and everything and I will SHOW u all these things and more!! And u will not be able to explain any of them apart from them being acts of God! But if they don’t workout… Then I will renounce my belief in GOD!
That be really cool actually, the Greatest Magician and Mind-boggler of our time Derren Brown! against… Moabi… A Believer! ha? Could work!!
Agh! *excited*
I love tv specials, will it be out on dvd soon?
Haha, I know, wait for it to air first!
xxx
🙂
Faith healers to tarot card readers all pray on the needy. I agree faith in your god is a wonderful thing and should not be discouraged as religion on the whole has given us the moral guidelines by which we live. Still in times of pain we will turn to someone for help. In those cases there are always the wolves waiting to take advantage. I will be watchin ta Derren
Texas…Derren came to Texas? My home. Yes, one of the centers of the bible belt, but although I’m sure it wasn’t lacking people who want to believe in faith healers, but Texas is not as backward a place as many Britons believe. Majority politically and religiously conservative, yes, but we are also home to the ‘second silicon valley’, great universities and an economically resilient state. I hope Faith Healer doesn’t reinforce stereotypes.
Thank you for having the courage to confront this fraud; I trust this sensitive subject has been well treated by hands as capable as yours.
Sadly, one of these televangelists (Robert Tilton) takes money from my very own Grandmother. I think the con-artist is Internet based now. Makes me so angry, and I can do nothing. I’m so happy to see Derren take this on.
Sounds fascinating, and important.
Am concerned about the scheduling though. Attacking a branch of the Christian church (albeit one as destructive as you claim) on Easter Sunday seems calculated to shock. I hope viewers will see beneath the headlines.
I once saw a group of faith healers practicing for free on the street. They asked if I needed any help so I politely told them that I didn’t think they had anything to offer to anyone. They seized the opportunity to exploit a vulnerable, and probably dying, elderly lady who had been kept in reserve on the sidelines.The elderly lady told me that doctors had determined that her cancer was untreatable,but faith healers had gone to work and left “only traces of cancer”.
I wonder how “having only traces of cancer” differs from “having cancer”. I’m not a medical professional, so maybe there is some reality in that. I suspect that she is probably very ill now though.It angered me that they could be so exploitative,but more worrying is that they genuinely seemed to believe in what they were doing.
Just got back up North from a 36 hr, 400 mile round away-day-and-a-half overnighter to Norwich where we saw “Svengali”. 110% entertainment. Well done Derren. I slept like log after the show but had a couple of bizzarre associated dreams to boot 😉 We’ll try and catch you later into the tour. The secrets of your show are safe with us.
Give the term “COME OUT!!!” a whole new meaning.
How will we here in the USA be able to see this, legally?
Also was hoping that I could help Derren anytime he is in USA, I sent a email a year ago stating that.
im seeing jedward on the 25th!!!!
well wanna watch it tho :/
This looks amazing, and I’m sure it will be. Hopefully it will lead people to realise how “faith healing” preys on the vulnerable, and faith healers are just scam artists who don’t even have to be good at scamming.
awesome
I am all for exposing criminals and fraudsters, only if while in the process it doesn’t demonise Christianity, especially the denominations that believe in the very real (believe it or not) power of gifts from the Holy Spirit. If you don’t want to believe in such gifts, its only your loss and I don’t understand why people try to convert atheists into believers… it’s their loss at the end of the day, Christians shouldn’t waste their breath.
the mighty derren at his most frrrr-oh-shus! i dunno whether to commend ya fer balls or insanity, pulling that kinda thing off in texas! :0 anyway, i hope ya get to hook up with marjoe gortner some day–the most outspoken of the former “healers”.
btw, it’s well documented that some people do shoulder the blame for their illnesses–they keep smoking, drinking/drugging to excess, not wearing condoms, etc. and they do know better.
I look forward to this a lot! As a Christian it really does disgust me what people do in the name of God (it would disgust me even if I wasn’t Christian but it’s an extra kick in the teeth). I look forward to seeing how much of this disgraceful industry you expose and I hope that a lot of vulnerable people will learn from it instead of seeing it as an attack on their faith
I do believe ill have to 40D it as I’m coming to see you at Sunderland that night!!!! Will be the 2nd time Ive seen you. Excited does not even cover it 🙂
Why do you not do a show about the placibo effect? I think this could be a great show and show how the power of the mind is amazing and can make people do sub human things.
Wayne
My dad is a member of one of these churches and when I went to visit him he took me to the church. There, they first got me to fill in a form then the whole sermon was subliminally centered around me. Was so shoddy, I had also purposefully brought along an NLP book to my dad’s house to make him aware I knew their shoddy tactics. Stinkin rich the pastor was too. I just wonder how many people come to their church and get sucked into it all. Unfair for financial gain.
Moabi: Derren may be a bit busy, what with the theatre tour and all that. You might want to try James Randi. He’ll give you a million dollars if you can substantiate your claim in an independent test. Further information can be found here: http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/1m-challenge/challenge-application.html
Ian: Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. It is plain to see that none of the vegetarians I know have (to my knowledge) engaged in mass genocide. However, it is less obvious to me that some faith healers aren’t scam artists (if indeed they aren’t). They perform the exact same stunt as the frauds, after all.
Same reason I’m skeptical of Uri Geller — if I can do the things he does without special powers, then where is my evidence that he has those powers?
Coming to watch the show tomorrow in Norwich, Im so excited !! Been waiting eagerly since we ordered the tickets!! Hope for a photo opportunity after or at least an autograph, im a huge fan 😀
😀
Yep, as you say at the end of the article you hope that British and/or intelligent believers will see past these idiots … and thankfully I can tell you that we have been on to them for a fair while. Its hard to see how anything that they say fits with the Bible – even if you really twist it out of shape.
On the flip side we hope that non ‘believers’ like you don’t dismiss us all out of hand as like these [insert swearword here]. Most of us appreciate that others have decided not to believe – and it’s ultimately there choice. However the media (like you!) often seen to label us as simpletons with no sense of personal space.
I’m looking forward to the special – they’re always good – just hoping that you don’t make too many broad sweeping claims about the rest of us!
I can’t wait! It sounds so interesting and thought provoking and will hopefully shed some light on this fraudulent industry 😉 thank you in advance Derren for what I am positive will be another breathtaking special 😉 x
@Ian 1 – Derren can’t afford to alienate his audience by saying this, but I can. Yes, all healing in the name of God is a fraud.
@Ian 2 (what is it with the Ians today?) – Religion did NOT magically give us the gift of morality. We conceived it then attributed it to imaginary deities. If you want to have faith in something, have faith in that gooey organ between your ears.
Keep up the good work, will retweet it and share it on facebook, obviously not enough education out there about these people or not enough of teaching people how to use their minds and think for themselves and learn to question more