New Derren Brown TV Special
On Easter Monday, April 25th at 9pm, my new special DERREN BROWN: MIRACLES FOR SALE will air on C4. This is hot off the press, so I have no artwork to show you as yet.
This is the special about faith-healing that some of you will have heard about. It has been the most intensely difficult project that I have attempted: to train an ordinary member of the public as a faith healer, then take him out to Texas, the heart of the Bible Belt, and try to pass him off as the real deal. We filmed this at the end of last year amidst concerns that we had bitten off far more than we could chew.
The film we made is driven by a desire to expose what I consider to be a foul and dangerous fraud at the expense of the sick, the needy and the faithful all over the world. It is not a comment on the church, or belief, or even, before some people get upset, the idea that God can or can’t heal. It is about a specific fraud, a greedy trick that has nothing to do with God whatsoever, beyond the fact that his name gets shouted around a lot. We made the show with the involvement of Christians and pastors who had been involved in that particular scene.
No faith healer has ever been able to provide evidence of a single miraculous healing ever having had occurred. Some when pushed have offered a few success stories, but when those ‘healed’ people have been approached, they turn out to be the same as before, worse than ever, dead, or not to have had the ailment in the first place. What does seem to happen, though, is a cleverly-engineered emotional event brings people into a state of hype that releases adrenalin, which acts as a pain killer. People in the audience with low-level ailments that can respond to such pain relief – combined with a huge amount of expectation and a desire to be healed, or ‘close to the magic’ – will commonly find themselves pain-free and step forward when asked to. There then follows, at the larger events, a filtering process where stewards send back anyone with a serious or visible ailment (such as an arm missing) and test the remaining arthritics and bad-back sufferers to see if they can display a convincing pantomime of having been healed (touching toes and so on). There are other tricks to seemingly cure the blind and deaf which I will also demonstrate on the show. These poor people are then brought up on stage in their heightened state to bounce around and think they’re healed while the truly afflicted are left to believe God hasn’t taken much of an interest. It’s very disturbing to see the rows of the seriously disabled on drip machines, in wheelchairs and even hospital beds, ignored and invisible, safely behind the TV cameras’ reach at the big-name events. Or to hear of the chronically afflicted being carried to these rallies around America by families who spend every last penny they earn in hope that the man on stage might channel a little of God in their direction. A wake of despair is left behind by these charlatans, made up of hundreds of thousands of people who receive no healing or only temporary pain relief, and are encouraged to blame themselves for not having enough faith when they find nothing’s improved.
And then there’s the money. This is the hub of the whole operation. The financial motivation seems to be closely linked to something called the Prosperity Gospel, which has to be the most perverse and self-serving piece of scripture-twisting I have ever come across. It was loudly preached by Oral Roberts and made popular in the 90s, and takes the rather lovely idea of ‘sow and ye shall reap’ and re-defines it as a financial incentive. Jesus bestows his blessings in the form of money. How do you get these blessings? You first give money. More than you can afford, otherwise it doesn’t count. Jesus will repay you hundredfold. If he doesn’t, you probably didn’t give enough, or perhaps you have secret sin or not enough faith. And to whom do you give your money? Your preacher, naturally. You might want to read that through again if this logic is something new to you. Not surprisingly, the big name preachers earn far more than any Hollywood A-lister from this system. Proof of the fact that Jesus bestows his blessings in the form of money? The stinking richness of your pastor. Perhaps his fleet of private jets might just convince you. And these donations come in not just from a mesmerised flock gathering twice on a Sunday, they flood in from millions of people on mailing lists which form the backbone of the big business of faith healing. The TV rallies, the crusade events, are all designed to encourage people to sign up and send in a sizeable chunk of their earnings every month. Cash floods in tax-free (for as long as you say it’s a church you are pretty much left alone by the IRS) and is spent on lifestyles that in some cases reach beyond imaginable luxury. People imagine perhaps that the money goes somewhere worthwhile to support God’s work. It’s disheartening watching the sick and the elderly put cash they can’t afford into the donation buckets at these vast crusades when I hear of how one big-name healer spent thousands of dollars after a rally, in said cash, on hotel room service and rent boys.
The healers perform their shows over here too: I recently went to see a couple of the current main men at venues in London and have never felt such a heady mixture of disgust and deep pity. A girl behind me screamed to her friend ‘There’s your proof God can heal!’ as we watched a man climb out of his wheelchair on stage; in her delight, she missed the moment later when he collapsed unhappily back into it once the cameras had been swiftly pointed away from him. At least it was his own chair: another common trick is to quietly stick someone with a bad back into one of the healer’s own wheelchairs to ‘make things comfortable’ for them, so that once they are brought before the crowd, the glistening man of God can command them to rise from a chair they didn’t need in the first place. Praise the Lord.
The project was hugely difficult because a big business like faith healing is almost impenetrable. We tried to speak to those who had worked alongside the current big-name healers, as we knew of a few who had been allowed in the inner circles of trust and knowing the depths of the corruption had eventually turned against it. But these are people who live in fear. They were told for years by their charismatic, ruthless leaders that they lived under a curse and that to leave the clan would result in God ending their lives. Disturbingly, that may not always be too far from the truth: we heard of a couple of witnesses who had been brought to testify against a healer and had died mysteriously of heart attacks the night before the trial. Something dark may be afoot.
There is, as one might hope, a growing scepticism in Britain amongst Christians towards these so-called healers. Although I don’t hide my own lack of religious belief, my repulsion at this scam comes as much from my days as a Christian as it does from simply being a human being observing ego- and money- driven fraud. It was a gruelling journey to penetrate the world of that fraud in the small way we could, with our own particular journey of seeing if an ordinary guy could pass as a real healer. I hope that the ranks of intelligent believers will feel the same concern at our findings as the rest of the viewers.
Hi derren , seat no N3 Norwich Thursday night.I’m a vet got degrees in astronomy and chemistry and Mensa iq and suffer severe depression tried everything but 24 hrs after show still feeling g8 positive confident and can’t stop talking,!,thank you sooooo much 🙂
I really can’t wait to watch this and a fascinating read too. Not only a sure to be incredible Derren Brown special, it’ll be a welcome break from revision!
Clearly by the scripture twisting and “The Prosperity Gospel” you might refer to the irony that the Pastors, Preachers and their churches seem to negate the fury of Jesus – when he went into the Temple and overthrew the tables of the moneylenders and declared it a “Den of Robbers” Quite how no follower has spotted this when handing over their money.
People who are in such a vulnerable state who try and and seek answers to healing or indeed try to find proof that their God is there for them answering their prayers are too often sucked into believing anything through sheer desperation and mass hysteria…as you know the power of suggestion is an incredible force and tapped into a persons mind could make a person believe black was white etc. Healers often prey on the fact that a person still has a hope and it is the power of hope that keeps people believing a miracle can happen…I don’t disbelieve that some incredible healing can occur, but never with such people and not enough credible research is ever carried out for us all to be convinced. I look forward to seeing your programme and exposing the vile people that do so much harm.
When are we going to change the laws and make it illegal? Something needs to be done
Bravo, bravo, bravo, Derren!!!
I have similar experiences and goals as you as far as exposing these frauds is concerned.
Keep up the good work!
Shenko
Saw you last night in Norwich Theatre Royal. Didnt know what to expect to be quite honest. AMAZED.
Me and my Mum are booking for tickets in London. You have inspired me!
Thank you for taking your time to sign my book, and take a photo with me. You are devoted to your fans, and your a lovely chap! 🙂
Really hope I can see your show again, and hope I can meet you again!
THANK YOU !!!!!
This isn’t about proving or disproving faith healing as a whole. This is about proving that it can be done by other means, it’s not an attack on any religion, it’s just Derren showing how it could be done to make money from ill and dying people.
The thing that gets me is, how do fraudulent faith-healers condone pretending to heal a terminally ill child knowing that they will not get better and still taking their money? Is money more important than morality?
It sickens me to think that there are people out there with the capacity to do this and still get away with it, taking advantage of a persons “hope” for petty cash.
On a positive note. I personally can not wait for this one-off and would love to see Derren on TV more
Derren should be a Daybreak presenter… :3
Sounds great can’t wait to see it. You should also do one on the scumbag ‘mediums’ popping up all over the place preying on the bereaved and needy. Especially the big guns like Acorah and Stockwell who started it all and spawned hundreds of imitators now conning their way across the country.
WOOOOOOO! THANKS! I CAN’T WAIT!
Ahh time for some new DB =)
sounds great, D.
Codifier,
I doubt that Derren is concerned about alienating anybody, but other than that I agree. All god-based healing is a fraud, conscious or otherwise.
And if we really took our morality from sacred writings we would be screwed. In fact, just just looking around the world shows that the extent to which we take our morality from sacred writings is the extent to which we are screwed.
Well done, Derren for exposing these charlatans. I’m looking forward to seeing this.
I like this type of Derren Brown show, I can’t wait to see it. I guess it will be similar to Messiah?
As a Christian and a massive fan of Derren Brown I am looking forward to this show. Derren shall expose the fraud healers who pray on peoples emotions, this does not mean however that all are false. (Although a lot are)
Indeed Jesus says it himself “For false messiahs and false prophets will appear and perform great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect. See, I have told you ahead of time.”
I am sad to see someone posted that Christians wont watch this as it is against their belief system, this is incorrect. A true Christian wants to watch shows like this and respond to them openly.
I am a hypnotist.
People have experienced healing because they believed that hypnosis would help them.
And I’m quite happy to charge them cash for their own belief change.
Because I’m a hypnotist.
It’s very similar to faith healing, and some people take offence at the idea. But it works,and I love doing it. And my mind is constantly on the difference between what I do and wrongful manipulation (if any)
:O Boy, this sounds really interesting….and risky. I’ve made sure my night it free, no one is visiting and we’re not going anywhere….YAAAAY!!! Can’t wait to see this, I am sooooooo excited, as usual! 😀 Probably getting more Derren DVD’s………I told mum to forget chocolate eggs and a card for Easter….I’d rather watch Derren on my tv 😀 😀 😀 xxx If the phone rings on Monday night during the show, I will not be answering it. 😛
Codifier, all healing in the name of God is NOT a fraud. Healing that cannot be explained by medical science has been regularly documented at Lourdes and other places. It has been documented by physicians who are not necessarily Christians, and the documentation is posted for visitors to read and observe through photos, sworn statements, etc. When has any faith-healer been willing to submit to that kind of scrutiny?
At Lourdes (just to use one example), everyone is not healed, but no one is hounded for money. The healings that do take place at Lourdes are sustained in nature, and even those who do not receive physical healing rarely leave without feeling a great spiritual consolation and peace.
Don’t condemn what you don’t know.
I’m sure that this will be fantastic as usual. Please for the sake of all Americans would someone be so kind as to show it to Sarah Palin?
It’s rather personal for me as I used to work in the industry and have even naively participated in the stuff, very often the people involved truly believe that what they are doing is legitimate and successful which makes things even more difficult to expose and correct.
I seem to recall a section in the book “SuperFreakonomics” by Steven Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner that may demonstrate that chemotherapy isn’t much different and may only offer false hope which makes me wonder how many more frauds there are and whether biting into faith healing is just taking superficial nibbles out of the problem. Is our entire culture drenched in faith healing?
Really looking forward to this Derren. My dear mother in law tried to get help from a faith healer many years ago and throughout her life she continued to seek help for her arthritic pain in ‘any’ direction she could. In the end, the best help she received was through the medical profession.
The very thing these fraudulent monsters ‘prey’ on is our human desire to find an ‘easier softer way’ to deal with physical and/or emotional pain. They ‘totally rely’ on that degree of desperation to make their money…it’s so ugly.
Well done you for tackling such a tricky subject.
Interesting the subject of Lourdes just came up – about five years ago Richard Dawkins did a documentary in which he visited Lourdes to get the lowdown on ‘miracle cures’ from somone who actually worked there.
As it turns out there are millions of faithful visitors needing cures every year. He asked the cleric who ran the site how many cures had been attributed to it.
Out of several millions across the years he’d been running it there were only 57 ‘confirmed’ cures, and not a single one which couldn’t be accounted for by medical science. No miraculous regrowing of limbs, no spontaneous cataract disappearance. Statistically negligable given the enormous size of the test group.
The entire setup smacks of cognative bias with a bit of placebo effect thrown in for good measure.
I am glad about this, I wrote to you a while ago and asked if you would consider doing this. I am a Christian and like you will not change my beliefs but I also hate to see people being manipulated into giving money to very false faith healers. I will look forward to seeing the results.
Hi I must admit when I saw the advert for this programme my heart sank and I saw this as another attack on the Christian Church. Furthermore having read the blurb at the top of this header I have mixed feelings about this programme. I am a faith healer and put into practice what the Bible tells us, that Jesus went about doing in the bible. I don’t charge a fee and offer to pray for people who need healing whether this be emotional. physical or spiritual healing. God healed people in the bible and he does it today. Yeah, sure people do and have taken advantage of using God for their own purposes and ends, but hey even the bible did say people would operate with a counterfeit Jesus. I have personally prayed for people with health issues and after which they say they are better, fact!
Please Investigate me,
Jesus heals people all the time.
It is not faith healing though. When Jesus speaks to someone they get healed. Everything he does works.
best regards
Keith
Do you all have an update on that poor boy and his family that went to see Bronikov?
To Catherine A
Although some people may miraculously get better after they visit Lourdes it doesn’t mean that anything helped them to get better. I’m going to use a somewhat loose source in wikipedia, but it says approximately 200 million people have visited since 1860 and 67 miracles have been officially observed. It would be interesting to see if the chances of someone recovering on their own is around the same as a 67 in 200 000 000 chance = 0.0000335%. Obviously not everyone visiting is asking to be healed, but I’m just trying to say that the miracles could just be people recovering on their own.
If God exists, God wouldn’t heal someone simply because they visited a town in France. God would be everywhere. Having ‘holy locations’ sounds like a human limitation, not a God limitation
Derren,
I have a very similar background to yourself. I was a born again Chritian for 3 – 4 years until I picked so many holes in my own faith I had to reject it. But I’ve been there and seen the way faith healers work. James Randi has an excellent book called “Faith Healers” that is a must read for everyone Christian and non-Christian alike. It is good to see someone as gifted as you use your position within the public eye do something positive like this. God bless you my son… Seriously, Thanks for this Derren.
Derren, you appear to me to be a very reluctant atheist It seems that you are desperately looking for any reason to believe in Christianity and God. But to your credit, you are not willing to accept, or let stand any fraudulent demonstrations or beliefs. I hope you continue your quest. It seems to me that as much time and energy that you spend on this project, you make nothing financial from it, accepting only the satisfaction of honest inquiry as your reward.
As a fairly strong Catholic, and badly failed Christian ( just watched an old GHANDI tape) I give you my sincerest prayers that you continue the good fight for TRUTH. I just as sincerely hope that you reach the paradox of successful failure in your journey. An admirer
This sounds like a great show. On a similar theme, has anyone got any good tips/links for de-bunking glossolalia aka speaking in tongues? Thanks!
Just because Mr Derren here is going to be part of a TV documentary showing how probably miracles performed by these pastor are not true. It will probably be deemed a successful programme, exposing etc but that will not mean all miracles performed are fake and fraudulent. Jesus is very much alive i’ve witnessed people’s live being changed the sick being healed and lives imp[roved by similar prayers and these pastors How come these things don’t get aired by these critics. It would be good to report on both sides of the story
Really looking forward to this…I think it’ll be a real eye opener for us all.
Deb, why do you need tips/links to de-bunk speaking in tongues? Are you tring to get rid of it?
I wish that I’d known the date before having to travel. I hope that it will be on 4oD and repeated as well. I have been looking forward to this project for a long time.
– It will be on 4oD for a little while – WebTeam
Cannot wait to see this, the more Derren Brown the better! Thanks a lot Derren for taking the time to provide us shows like this. It really opens up peoples views too. Also I cannot wait to see Svengali on Thursday in Oxford!
Rob, a family member was recently telling me about their experiences of glossolalia during a chat we were having about worldviews. It’s not a subject I’ve come across before so I was looking for helpful information that explains the phenomenon without straying into the spirtual/supernatural.
I’m an atheist/humanist/bright/skeptic etc and it has been said that I have a tendency to monologue but only in English 😉
Hi Derren
As a struggling evangelical christian, who suffers from mental illness, I look forward to this program. I believe there is a lot of manipulation, attention-seeking and quest for money in many ‘christian healing ministries’.
My ex-husband, who divorced me after I was sectioned in hospital, now runs a ‘healing on the streets’ ministry, and ‘trains’ people in healing. I admit to still believing in God and Jesus – but I struggle that this man is now a ‘minor christian celebrity’ after the way he treated me.
If you ever want to try out your own abilities on someone with psychological/emotional difficulties, please let me know!!!!
I used to belong to a Vineyard Church whose pastor believes all this miracles, signs and wonders garbage. Was told dead people would rise from their dead state in my home town through his ministry – yes, I’m still waiting! Was told that if people were not healed it was because they had not enough faith (did he ever consider how much faith dead people had?) or there was sin in their life or their family going back generations perhaps! I am glad Derren is finally going to expose this disgraceful and knowingly deceitful scam practised by the Vineyard Church and other similar charismatic/pentecostal denominations. They are out ‘healing in the street’ but that is little more than a front to invite unsuspecting and needy people to their church.
“MIRACLES FOR SALE†One that would be priceless, would be an army of volunteers. Who would take on the task of providing solace to those who suffer, for free.
As an atheist whose evangelical family members have sent tens (likely hundreds) of thousands to these faith healers I applaud you for investigating these immoral criminals.
Gary Taylor, you say that ‘[you] have personally prayed for people with health issues and after which they say they are better, fact!’
A couple of questions…
Have ALL of the people you have prayed for got better?
Have you ever encountered anyone in your life who has got better from an illness without you having prayed for them?
If the answer to the first question is no or the answer to the second is yes then you can’t logically conclude that your praying had anything to do with people getting better. If the respective answeres are yes and no I can only conclude you have a very small circle of acquaintance
Wow! Yeah shocking. I can’t believe this goes on in the name of Jesus. It’s crazy and I wasn’t aware of it before reading about your show. Good for you for exposing them. I hope it’s shown in America too and people are exposed for the frauds they are!!
Great work, can’t wait to see it. Have booked the night off to watch it.
It sounds like it was quite stressful for you to film too, so I hope you are happy with the results and enjoy watching it too.
It’s gonna be a very good show, can’t wait!!!
Well done to all the team and especially you Derren. Good job as the Americans would say.
Xxx
Well done Derren,
You are a good man for confronting this issue face on.
These manipulating idiots are taking advantage of people even in the recession when people are financially weak. Firstly, they need to start paying taxes but better still they all should be closed down. I hope that you will discuss the variety of hypnotic techniques that these people use.
This is interesting. I just hope he mentions real faith-healers also. John G. Lake for example. Who had 100,00 verified healings in Spokane Washington and died without any money to his name. The state became the healthiest in America because the dying would come and be healed. I’m tired of show after show that only show abuses in Christianity. I hope this isn’t another one.
Deb – please watch – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZbQBajYnEc about speaking in tongues. This is a scientific study. P.S. concerning healing, my friend was healed by God recently and it has been medically verified 🙂 you don’t need to believe me but you can add me on facebook and i can link you to the person and you can find out.
The state became the healthiest in America because the dying would come and be healed.
Source please.
What a perfect tribute for Zombie Jesus Day. I only wish there were a way for those of us in the states to enjoy it. I’ve only just discovered your work and offer my admiration and thanks for exposing those who prey on the desperate and needy.
Samuel, you say your friend was healed by god and this was medically verified. I would be really interested in some links to the no doubt volumous amount of reportage an this amazing case!
I’m interested in how healing by a deity can be medically verified, I’ve always been under the impression that ‘Miracle’ cures worked outside the bounds of natural science so could therefore not be medically verified? Sure, a doctor can verify that someone has been cured, but how do they then go about proving that the cure was achieved by god?
i seen the preview video.. and you got in trouble with the police!!! i hope you or anyone in the crew, were arrested, thart is if you tried to go back in that place. really looking forward to it and it will be a early birthday treat as my birthday will be a week or so after the 25th. also, in my english class, we are all to write a letter to our fave celebs. i thought ‘derren brown’ so i need to know where do a few pupils send their letters if you want it to go to derren? i know you may be busy but me and my friend would be very grateful if he replied. apperently, we’re the most likely people out the entire first year to get a reply of somesort.
sounds amazing cant wait to watch it. and definatly cant wait for ur tour in bornemouth 3rd of june 2011 its going to b amazing!!!!!!!!!!xxxx
Looking forward to this, the more high profile rational thinkers (especially well liked ones like Derren) are out there the better. The world and media is completely out of balance in it’s representation of religion/supernatural vs rationality, anything supernatural or religion based seems to be the excepted reality these days, anything goes who needs proof, just choose whatever reality suits you! Anyone daring to challenge an unfounded belief is looked at as being an evil blasphemer intent on destroying people’s beliefs and hopes. To those that still cling to their belief in “the healing powers of god” simply ask yourself why there is not one a single PROVEN case of this EVER happening??